This will depend on the business and its values and whether better quality credits can be sourced from projects that are not too different in price from the cheapest ones available. As demand increases and if supply is constrained, the carbon price will rise. With this rise in carbon price, the more economically challenging project types with higher quality and more co-benefits will become more economically viable and as a result will find it easier to gain access to capital. As a result, these project types will be able to compete in the market more successfully with larger volumes of supply available.
The questions for a carbon insetting investment decision are:
a) whether you are in it for the long-term,
b) whether you care about the provenance of your carbon credits, and
c) whether you want to gain security of supply, control over that provenance, and insulate yourself from future carbon prices.
If the answer to these is yes, then carbon insetting is a sensible option to consider. The challenge then is whether you have access to the capital needed in order to build your “carbon credit factory” (establish your forest and carbon project). If you do, you will pay a lot for your carbon credits in the near-term, but significantly less annually in the future.
The overall economic test is the ‘effective carbon price’ across a cash flow period (e.g. 30 years). This involves calculating the total discounted costs across the cash flow period and dividing by the number of carbon credits produced in that period and comparing the projected cost/benefit of insetting with the equivalent for offsetting across that same cash flow. Although insetting projects have high costs at the beginning (capex), the significantly lower costs once the forest is established (opex) means that the overall effective carbon price can be lower than the offsetting alternative. This is why businesses are seriously looking at carbon insetting even from a purely financial perspective.