By Barbara Nebel, CEO thinkstep-anz
October 2026
Since 27 September, new rules on environmental claims have applied across the EU. While the rules are European, some of the questions behind them feel very relevant to businesses in Australia and New Zealand.
The advice about environmental claims is not new. Be specific. Have evidence. Make sure you can explain what you mean when you describe something as “sustainable”.
We have all heard that before.
So what makes the European changes interesting now?
Europe is moving beyond simply asking businesses to substantiate environmental claims. Under the EU's Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive, some common environmental marketing practices are now specifically prohibited or restricted.
That includes generic environmental claims such as “green” or “environmentally friendly”, unless they meet the required standard. There are new rules around sustainability labels. And businesses cannot claim that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse gas impact where that claim relies on offsetting emissions outside the product's value chain.
This raises an interesting question:
Does this mean businesses need more certification?
Not necessarily.
Do green claims now need to be independently verified?
Not every environmental claim needs independent third-party verification under the new European rules.
A business may, for example, have robust evidence to say:
“This product contains 65% recycled material.”
Or:
“The carbon footprint of this product is 18 kg CO2e.”
Or:
“Our Material Circularity Indicator is 0.72, calculated using using the MCI methodology developed with the Ellen MacArthur Foundation.”
These are specific, testable statements. Provided the evidence and methodology behind them are robust and the statements are not misleading, the new rules do not automatically third-party verification.
That is quite different from saying:
“This is an environmentally friendly product.”
Or:
“This product is sustainable.”
The broader the claim, the more it implies - and the harder it becomes to demonstrate what it actually means.
Under the new European rules, generic claims such as “green”, “eco-friendly” and “environmentally friendly” face specific restrictions unless recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim can be demonstrated.
And the qualification cannot simply be hidden elsewhere. It needs to be clear and prominent.
The EU Directive gives a useful example.
“Climate-friendly packaging” is a generic claim.
“100% of the energy used to produce this packaging comes from renewable sources” is a specific claim.
Specific. Substantiated. Transparent.
The alternative to another certification may simply be a better claim.
Rather than:
“Made from sustainable materials.”
Say:
“Contains 80% post-consumer recycled aluminium.”
Rather than:
“Better for the planet.”
Say:
“The cradle-to-gate carbon footprint has reduced from X kg CO2e to Y kg CO2e since 2022.”
Rather than:
“More circular.”
Say:
“The product has a Material Circularity Indicator of 0.72, calculated using [methodology].”
The the evidence, methodology and boundaries need to support what you actually say.
A calculation covering one environmental characteristic does not necessarily justify a claim about the environmental performance of the whole product.
Future claims are different
There is another important distinction around claims about what a business will achieve.
Statements such as:
“We will be net zero by 2035.”
Under the new European rules, claims about future environmental performance need to be supported by clear, objective, publicly available and verifiable commitments. They need a detailed and realistic implementation plan with measurable, time-bound targets and appropriate resources.
Progress also needs to be regularly verified by an independent third-party expert, with the findings made available to consumers.
Compare:
“Our product's current carbon footprint is X.”
with:
“Our product will be carbon neutral by 2030.”
The first is something you can measure now. The second is a promise about the future. Europe treats them differently.
What about certifications and ecolabels?
This is where third-party verification becomes particularly important.
The EU rules restrict sustainability labels that are neither established by a public authority nor based on a qualifying certification scheme.
And a certification scheme is not simply a company developing some criteria and creating a green logo.
A qualifying scheme needs transparent and publicly available rules and objective monitoring of compliance by a competent third party independent of both the scheme owner and the business being certified.
A few years ago, we wrote about 10 things to look for in a credible environmental certification.
One of the points we made then feels particularly relevant today:
When your logo sits next to a certification logo, your reputation becomes connected with theirs.
If you are choosing a certification or ecolabel, particularly for a product sold in Europe, credibility is not the only question. You also need to understand how the scheme operates.
- Who developed the criteria?
- Are they publicly available?
- Who verifies compliance?
- Is that verifier genuinely independent?
And, perhaps most importantly:
- What does the certification actually prove?
A certification can be perfectly credible while still not substantiating the broader environmental claim you want to make.
How does this compare with Australia and New Zealand?
Australia and New Zealand are not starting from scratch on green claims.
In Australia, environmental claims are already covered by the Australian Consumer Law. The ACCC expects businesses to make accurate and truthful claims, have evidence to back them up, explain conditions and qualifications clearly, and consider the overall impression created by words, images, colours and symbols.
New Zealand takes a similar approach under the Fair Trading Act. The Commerce Commission says environmental claims should be truthful, accurate, specific and substantiated.
If you make an environmental claim, you need evidence to support it and the overall impression must not mislead.
What makes the new European approach interesting is that it goes further in several areas.
|
European Union |
Australia |
New Zealand |
|
|
Misleading environmental claims |
Prohibited |
Prohibited under Australian Consumer Law |
Prohibited under Fair Trading Act |
|
Claims need substantiation |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Generic claims such as “green” and “eco-friendly” |
Specifically restricted unless requirements are met |
Not automatically prohibited, but must be substantiated and not misleading |
Not automatically prohibited, but must be accurate, specific and substantiated |
|
Product climate claims based on offsets |
Certain claims specifically prohibited |
Not categorically prohibited, but claims must not mislead and the role of offsets needs to be clear |
Not categorically prohibited under the general Fair Trading Act approach |
|
Sustainability labels |
Specific rules - generally need to be established by a public authority or based on a qualifying certification scheme |
Primarily covered by rules against misleading and deceptive conduct |
Primarily covered by rules against misleading and deceptive conduct |
|
Independent verification of every specific environmental claim |
No general requirement |
No general requirement |
No general requirement |
|
Claims about future environmental performance |
Specific requirements, including independent third-party verification of progress |
Must have reasonable grounds and not mislead |
Must have reasonable grounds and not mislead |
The difference can be summarised quite simply. Australia and new Zealand continue to take a largely principles-based approach:
Can we substantiate this claim, and could it mislead someone?
Europe now adds another question for some claims:
Is this type of claim or label permitted in the first place?
What does the New Zealand-EU Free Trade Agreement have to do with this?
The New Zealand-EU Free Trade Agreement has been in force since May 2024 and is designed to make it easier for New Zealand businesses to trade with Europe.
Sustainability also features prominently in the agreement, including commitments relating to climate and environmental standards.
That creates an interesting combination:
Access to the European market is becoming easier. The rules around environmental claims in that market are becoming tighter.
The claims, ecolabels and certifications travelling with a product need to work in the market where that product is being sold.
Are our environmental claims and certifications ready to travel with our products?
What role can EPDs play in substantiating environmental claims?
Environmental Product Declarations are a good example of a different approach.
An EPD does not say that a product is “green”. That is one of its strengths.
An EPD provides standardised environmental information about a product based on life cycle assessment. EPDs are independently verified against defined standards, Product Category Rules and programme requirements.
Instead of another broad green badge, a business gets verified environmental data that can support specific claims.
For example, an EPD may provide the evidence to say:
“The cradle-to-gate global warming potential of this product is X kg CO2e.”
Or, where the data, boundaries and methodology support the comparison:
“We have reduced the cradle-to-gate carbon footprint of this product by X% compared with our previous product.”
But having an EPD does not automatically justify saying:
“Our product is sustainable.”
The claim still needs to match what the evidence demonstrates. That distinction is important.
An EPD verifies the environmental information. It does not turn that information into a blanket environmental endorsement.
Better information rather than more green badges
For a long time, environmental communication has often tried to reduce complex environmental performance to a simple word or logo.
Green. Sustainable. Eco-friendly. Carbon neutral.
But customers, procurement teams and other decision-makers increasingly need the information behind those words.
- What has actually improved?
- By how much?
- Compared with what?
- Over which part of the life cycle?
- Using which methodology?
- Has the underlying information been independently verified?
So the response to Europe's new rules may not be:
“We need another certification.”
It may be:
“We need better information and a more specific claim.”
Sometimes the answer will be certification.
Sometimes it will be an independently verified EPD.
Sometimes it will be a well-defined calculation, a transparent methodology and a specific statement about what the product actually does.
Specific. Substantiated. Transparent.
If you are reviewing environmental claims, deciding whether independent verification would add value, or working through which certification or environmental declaration is appropriate, reach out. We are always happy to look at what sits behind the claim and work through the options with you.